When gig workers cancel: Two ways to reduce staffing risks
Amsterdam, November 18, 2026
Erik Kommol joined Amsterdam Business School as an Assistant Professor in September 2026. His research focuses on decision-making, collective intelligence, and digital innovation. In this blog, he shows what organisations can do to reduce staffing risks when hiring Gig workers.


When gig workers cancel: Two ways to reduce staffing risks
Imagine managing a busy restaurant, warehouse, or event. You have hired several workers through a gig platform for an upcoming shift. But shortly before the shift begins, one of them cancels. Suddenly, you are understaffed and need to find a replacement.
How can organisations manage situations like this? Our research shows that organisations manage the risk of cancellations in two ways: by lowering the likelihood of cancellations through greater reliance on trusted workers, and by reducing the impact of cancellations through additional staffing.
Gig platforms make it easy to find flexible staff, but they also come with challenges. Organisations have limited control over whether gig workers show up for their assignments. Traditional HR approaches, such as improving working conditions to strengthen employee engagement or using disciplinary measures to manage attendance, can be harder to apply. Gig work is often short-term, and workers frequently operate as independent contractors. Measures introduced by the platforms themselves may not always be effective either. This means organisations often need to find their own ways to deal with cancellations.
How common are cancellations?
We analysed more than 400,000 job postings on a gig platform over four years. About 16% of job matches were canceled by workers. Cancellations also appear to affect organisations' willingness to use these platforms: those that experienced cancellations were more likely to discontinue their platform use.
Yet many organisations continue to rely on gig workers. Rather than depending entirely on the platform to prevent cancellations, they adjust their own hiring practices to manage the risk.
Two ways to manage cancellation risk
Theoretically, organisations can approach cancellation risk in two ways: making cancellations less likely or reducing the problems they cause. Our research shows that organisations use both approaches.
1. Making cancellations less likely: Hire trusted workers
One approach is to hire workers with whom the organisation has had positive experiences before. On the platform we studied, organisations can give these workers preferential access to new assignments. After experiencing a cancellation, organisations were approximately 14% more likely to give previously favored workers this preferential access.
Why might this help? Having worked with someone before gives organizations a better sense of how reliable that person is. Workers may also be more likely to keep their commitments if they see opportunities to receive future assignments.
Our additional analyses show that this response is associated with fewer cancellations. Building relationships with reliable gig workers therefore appears to be a useful way to reduce cancellation risk.
2. Reducing the impact: Hire additional workers
Another approach is to recruit more workers for an assignment. This gives organisations some extra staffing capacity if someone cancels.
After experiencing a cancellation, organisations increased the number of workers they sought to hire per job by approximately 3%.
But there is an interesting trade-off. Hiring additional workers was associated with a higher probability that at least one worker would cancel. At the same time, it was associated with a lower probability that all workers hired for a job would cancel.
In other words, recruiting extra workers does not necessarily prevent cancellations. But it can help reduce the risk of an assignment being left completely unstaffed.
What does this mean for HR professionals?
Organisations using gig platforms can take several practical steps to manage cancellations:
Build a pool of trusted workers. Keep track of workers who have performed well and offer them opportunities to return. Previous positive experiences can help organisations identify more reliable workers for future assignments.
Plan for possible staffing gaps. Think about how disruptive a cancellation would be for each assignment. Where understaffing could cause serious problems, recruiting additional workers may provide a useful buffer. Of course, the benefits need to be weighed against the extra costs.
Use data to make better staffing decisions. Track previous hiring experiences, cancellation patterns, and the effects of cancellations. This information can help organisations decide which workers to recruit and how many they need.
The key takeaway is that managing cancellation risk is not just about preventing workers from canceling. It is also about being prepared when cancellations happen. By combining trusted workers with additional staffing capacity where needed, organisations can better manage the uncertainty of hiring through gig platforms.
GenAI Use Note
Generative AI tools (OpenAI’s ChatGPT 5.6 Sol) were used to support editorial tasks such as refining sentence structure, language polishing, and improving clarity. I cross-checked, critically evaluated, and refined the outputs of the AI tools and maintain full responsibility for the content of the article.
About the author
Erik Kommol joined Amsterdam Business School as an Assistant Professor in September 2026, following a PhD at WU Vienna and a postdoctoral position at VU Amsterdam. His research focuses on decision-making, collective intelligence, and digital innovation. This research project is joint work with Joey van Angeren and Mark Boons.